Return to Midcontinent Plains home page
RETHINKING GRASSLAND REGIONALISM
John C. Hudson
Program in Geography
1810 Hinman Avenue
Northwestern University
Evanston, IL 60208-1310
and
Dwight A. Brown
Department of Geography
University of Minnesota
Minneapolis, MN 55455

Abstract
A test of the Midcontinent Plains as a climatically defined
grassland stretching from Canada to the Rio Grande is offered in the vegetation
reconstructions of a series of models beginning with Köppen, Thornthwaite,
and Holdridge, and extended more recently by efforts to simulate biomes
using global climate models. Current attempts to derive grasslands
(and other biomes) from climate models are concerned with environmental
change likely to result from increased levels of CO2. The former emphasis
placed on precipitation deficiency as defining characteristics of grasslands
has given way to a greater interest in temperature patterns because of
the link between CO2 and climate change. Regional interpretations
based on the Köppen, Thornthwaite, and Holdridge models have been
challenged because these models are based on the mapped correspondence
of climate and vegetation patterns rather than on biochemical theories
aout plant growth processes. The photosynthetic pathways corresponding
to the processes used by plants to fix carbon and plant height lead to
the definition of C3, C4 shortgrass, and C4 tallgrass groupings of Plains
grasses. Abundance maps based on the three groups show a regional
differentiation only roughly corresponding to climatic differences.
spatial statistical analysis reveals that local variability can be as great
as variability within the entire region. Broad, climate-based regionalizations
may be less important than topographic position or other site factors in
explaining the existence and distribution of grasses.
Key words: Grasslands, Midcontinent Plains, biome models, photosynthetic
types,
grassland region maps, climate change.
View or download entire article 29 pages, including 13 maps, two figures, and 1 table.